Sea Ice
- About
- Imprint
- Scenarios
- Arctic Marine Transportation by 2030
- Introduction
- Aim of this Study
- Key Factor Classification
- Deļ¬nitions of Key Factors and Future Projections
- 1. Climate
- 2. Legal framework
- 3. Global Trade Dynamics – Global economic growth
- 4. Safety of other Routes
- 5. Socio-economic impact of global climate change
- 6. Oil Price
- 7. Major Arctic Shipping Disasters
- 8. Windows of Operation
- 9. Maritime Insurance Industry
- 10. Collaboration in resource extraction by China, Japan and Russia
- 11. Transit fees
- 12. Conflict between indigenous and commercial use
- 13. Arctic Enforcers
- 14. Energy sources for propulsion
- 15. New resource discovery
- 16. World Trade Patterns
- 17. Regulation in the Arctic
- Consistency matrix
- Scenarios
- Suggest Wild Cards
- Suggest Key Factors
- References
- Glossary
- Yakutat Community Energy Scenarios
- Introduction to Scenario-Management
- The Consistency and Robustness Analysis
- 1. Key Factors and their Future Projections
- 2. Assigning plausibility values to future projections
- 3. Projection Bundles
- 4. Assigning consistency values
- 5. Obtaining overall consistency values for the projection bundles
- 6. The combinatorial problem of the consistency analysis
- 7. The Robustness of a projection bundle
- Disruptive event analysis – Wild Cards
- ScenLab v1.7 Client download
- Arctic Marine Transportation by 2030
4. Safety of other Routes
AMSA Evaluation: Importance: 7, Uncertainty: 12, Sum: 19
Classification: Economics, Politics, Technology
World wide shipping routes pass through several bottlenecks. Many of which,
such as the Strait of Malacca, the Suez canal and the Panama canal, lie in potentially
very unstable regions. Hence, there are two distinct pressures on equatorial
shipping routes: i) routes get over-crowded and ii) threads by political conflicts,
piracy and terrorism [Bureau, 2007].
As of today, the amount of goods transported on the maritime shipping routes
increases every year [Association].
4.1 Increasing pressure on other routes – high piracy
Plausibility: 0.3
The bottlenecks of the marine shipping industry are congested and demand is
growing rapidly. To minimize accidents all large vessels intending to pass through
maritime bottlenecks are required to install expensive equipment for course control
and collision avoidance.
After a decline in piracy incidents in the middle of the first decade of the 21st
century (IMB CITATION HERE) terrorist discovered the hijacking of oil and gas
tankers as a strategy to exert pressure on the western world by threatening to
cause oil spills and gas explosions. It is increasingly expensive to guard or insure
ships against pirates attacks. Some countries look away while pirates operate in
their waters.
4.2 Stably increasing pressure
Plausibility: 0.4
The bottlenecks of the marine shipping industry are congested and demand is
growing, but can be planned for. To minimize accidents all large vessels intending
to pass through maritime bottlenecks are required to install expensive equipment
for course control and collision avoidance.
4.3 Stable demand
Plausibility: 0.3
The demand for marine shipping is stable, but not growing appreciably. This
might have several reasons: i) growing competition from very cheap air craft; ii)
low overall economic growth; or iii) regional conflicts.